Let’s be real—trying to be liked by everyone can seem like the easiest path when you’re a leader, but just being that “nice guy” who says yes to everything isn’t the way to make a real impact. True leadership is all about authenticity, guts, and yes, actual kindness. There’s a big gap between leading with kindness and just people-pleasing—and understanding that could totally change how you lead your team or company.
So, What’s the Big Difference?
Kindness means being honest, caring, and doing the right thing even when it’s tough. Kind leaders aren’t afraid to give real feedback and have tough conversations, but they still show empathy and respect.
Niceness, though, is more about keeping things smooth on the surface—avoiding conflict, sharing only good news, and putting popularity ahead of progress. It’s friendly, but kind of shallow.
While both kindness and niceness can make work feel good for a bit, only kindness builds trust and respect that lasts.
What Goes Wrong with the “Nice Guy” Approach?
Ø Dodging Tough Talks: Nice leaders often avoid giving honest feedback or dealing with problems head-on because they don’t want to ruffle any feathers. The trouble is, ignoring problems just makes them worse.
Ø Losing Authenticity: If you’re always agreeable, people might start to see you as insincere or wishy-washy. Folks notice when a leader is more focused on being liked than doing what’s right.
Ø Letting Mediocrity Slide: Not challenging your team or setting clear standards just leads to “meh” results. Being too nice can mean you’re giving up chances for growth and improvement.
Ø Burning Out: Trying to please everyone is exhausting! You end up stretched too thin, losing sight of your own goals and values.
Why Kindness Wins
Ø Trust and Respect: Kind leaders are honest and consistent. They’re brave enough to give tough feedback but do it with care. Teams trust and respect leaders who act with integrity.
Ø Real Growth: Kindness means helping your team grow, even if it’s uncomfortable. Push people to improve and always have their backs when they need support.
Ø Openness and New Ideas: When leaders are kind, people feel safe sharing their opinions and trying new things. That’s how creativity and teamwork really take off.
Ø Motivation and Loyalty: When folks know you genuinely care, they step up and give their best. Kindness builds a feeling of belonging and purpose.
Ø Better Culture All Around: Teams led by kind people are more collaborative, resilient, and positive. That kind of vibe attracts top talent and helps everyone thrive.
How to Lead with Kindness—For Real
Ø Be Honest: Don’t sugarcoat feedback. Say what needs to be said, but do it with empathy.
Ø Set Clear Expectations: Be upfront about what you want and where you’re headed. Hold everyone (including yourself) accountable, but be fair.
Ø Show Gratitude: Celebrate wins—big or small. A simple thank you goes a long way.
Ø Practice Empathy: Take time to listen and understand where people are coming from. Support your team as whole people, not just workers.
Ø Make Tough Calls with Heart: When you have to make hard choices, do it thoughtfully and be upfront about why.
Ø Take Care of Yourself, Too: Model balance and self-kindness. Encourage your team to look after themselves as well.
Kindness vs. Just Being Popular: A Quick Story
Picture two leaders: Alex, who says yes to everything, avoids conflict, and wants to be everyone’s favorite; and Jamie, who’s friendly and approachable but isn’t afraid to have tough conversations. Over time, Alex’s team gets stuck and afraid to speak up, while Jamie’s team grows, trusts each other, and tackles problems head-on. The difference? Kindness builds a strong foundation for real progress; chasing approval just leads to stagnation.
The Courage to Lead Kindly
Kindness isn’t weakness—it takes guts to make tough calls, tell the truth, and put the team’s needs above just being liked. Real kindness is about strength, empathy, and sticking to your values. That’s what inspires people to follow you—not because they have to, but because they want to.
Bottom Line
Being the “nice guy” might keep things smooth in the short run, but it’s kindness that really changes teams and the people in them. Kindness is honest, brave, and human. It builds trust, drives growth, and makes you a leader people won’t forget.
Honestly, people might remember if you were nice—but they’ll always remember if you were kind.
To your greater courage to be kind,
Peter Mclees, Leadership Coach, Trainer and Performance Consultant
SMART DEVELOPMENT
Take the Next Step...
Interested
in learning how to develop your organization's leadership capability,
culture, and employee engagement? We begin with a collaborative
discovery process identifying your unique needs and business issues. To
request an interview with Peter Mclees please
contact: Email: petercmclees@gmail.com or Mobile: 323-854-1713
Smart
Development has an exceptional track record helping service providers,
ports, sales teams, restaurants, stores, distribution centers, food
production facilities, wealth management services, third-party maintenance providers, real estate services,
nonprofits, government agencies and other businesses create a strong
culture, leadership bench strength, coaching skills and the teamwork
necessary for growth.
Having worked with several companies
throughout their growth cycle, we have valuable insights and strategies
that would help any late stage startup, small or medium sized company
achieve sustained growth and prosperity.
No comments:
Post a Comment