How to Fire Someone With Their Dignity in Tact

How to Fire Someone the Right Way

• Coordinate with HR, IT, and others to ensure a smooth exit process
• Ask to speak in private.
• Be direct and keep it short. (Ex. “I’ve called you in here because we’ve decided to let you go. Today will be your last day.”)
• Have a handout ready with all the necessary information.
• Offer job search resources.

Fired, laid off, let go, canned, terminated… The reason there are so many euphemisms for losing your job is because it’s a universally difficult step to take as a leader.

As most leaders are aware, firing someone on your team is no easy task, especially if it’s an employee you’ve come to know and care about. It’s difficult to deliver such a gut-punch!

However, there is only one right way to terminate an employee whether they are a friend or not, whether you like them or not.

First, Do Your Homework

Before I get into brass tacks, I’d advise you to first think over your relationship with the direct report being terminated.

Run through this list to make sure you’ve done everything you can to help this employee improve:

Note how many times you met with this employee one-on-one. Meeting regularly with each person on your team ensures personal attention, and opens up discussions on how they should be approaching their work. Did you give this person an opportunity to ask questions?

Think back on the feedback you delivered. Retrace your leadership steps: Did you deliver enough feedback? Did you orient them when they were veering off course? Did you give this employee a real chance to learn and improve?

Check in with your transparency. A firing sometimes occurs because of circumstances that are completely out of our control. Budget cuts, downsizing, and mergers are all commonplace. In these instances, the firing still shouldn’t come as a huge surprise. When rumblings from on-high suggest a major shift in personnel, it’s time to calmly inform the team.

Going through these points covers you in several ways: You can learn from some personal failures to improve and, if the direct report contests the termination, you can point to several moments when you attempted to help.

Time To Double Check With HR

Before firing someone, you should always consult with your company’s human resources.

Every country and state has varying laws when it comes to termination (note that terminating someone for their gender, ethnicity, or sexual preferences will deservedly land you with a lawsuit almost everywhere), and it’s important to educate yourself before committing to a constructive dismissal.

Get clear on the reason behind the termination, even if it’s not required by law (which might be the case if you live in an ‘at will’ state). Then gather all pertinent information for the employee being terminated: dates of when benefits expire, information regarding their last paycheck (including any vacation days that may be reimbursed), what they should do with any company equipment, and finally who they can contact for more information.

They’ll likely be in a state of shock, so having all of this ready for them and laid out clearly will help immensely going forward.

What To Say To Fire Someone With Their Dignity In Tact

Now let’s dive into the root of this issue: What do you actually say to fire an employee in the most respectful way possible?

You’re going to hate this, but…

Be direct and keep it short.

There won’t be any metaphors, magic words, or stories of personal failure that can soften the blow. Instead, tell them outright and give them a moment to absorb. It is the greatest kindness you can offer. This way there’s no bargaining, negotiating, or (fingers crossed) any arguing.

“Steve, the reason I’ve called you in here is that we’ve decided to let you go, and today will be your last day.”

Take a beat and allow them to take in the message. Then go into clear and concise information about their last paycheck, details about their benefits, and who they can contact if they have questions. If it seems that they’re too overwhelmed to focus on the details, have a handout ready with all the necessary information.

Feel free to accompany them to their desk to handle any passing inquiries from coworkers (“Hey Maggie, what’s going on?” can be a difficult question for them to answer at that time.) Or, if its company policy, let them know security will be in attendance as they gather their things as a formality.

Offer Support (That You Can Follow-Through On)
In a final act of kindness, offer your support in whatever way you feel is most effective to help the person find a more suitable position.

Be certain that the help you offer is something you’re prepared to give. Promises are great, but if you’re not willing or able to meet those expectations then it’s best to leave things as is.

No matter what, being fired is rough news, and there’s no way everyone will leave smiling. That being said, to fire someone with their dignity in tact you first have to check in that you’ve done everything possible to make them successful, deliver the news simply, give them all the details concerning benefits and paychecks, and offer sincere support moving forward.

My best,

Peter Mclees, Leadership Coach, Trainer and Performance Consultant

SMART DEVELOPMENT

Email: petercmclees@gmail.com  or  Mobile:323-854-1713

Smart Development has an exceptional track record helping service providers, ports, sales teams, restaurants, stores, distribution centers, food production facilities, nonprofits, government agencies and other businesses create a strong culture, leadership bench strength, coaching skills and the teamwork necessary for growth. 

Having worked with several companies throughout their growth cycle, we have valuable insights and strategies that would help any late stage startup, small or medium sized company achieve sustained growth and prosperity.